90 Day Fiancé star Josh Weinstein has moved on from his relationship with Natalie Mordovtseva, but it seems he may still be dating within the franchise! The Arizona native briefly spoke about his budding romance in the trailer for the 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2 tell-all, and host Shaun Robinson teased that his new girlfriend is a familiar face. In Touch breaks down all the clues about the mystery woman’s identity ahead of her reveal in the tell-all.
Josh Weinstein’s New Girlfriend Teased in ‘90 Day: The Last Resort’ Season 2 Tell-All Trailer
In the trailer for the tell-all, which is set to premiere its first part on March 31, 2025, Shaun asked Josh if he was seeing someone new after his relationship with Natalie came to an end. “Well, you know, I do like somebody a lot. We’ve been hanging out a lot,” he said, prompting a scoff from Natalie.
Shaun then teased that the producers invited “a new woman Josh has been seeing,” but she added, “Some of you might recognize her already.” This led many fans to speculate that Josh was dating another 90 Day Fiancé star.
Josh Weinstein Sparked Dating Rumors With ‘90 Day Fiance’ Star Jenn Potthast
A few weeks before the trailer dropped, Josh was spotted with Jenn Potthast, the older sister of 90 Day Fiancé season 5 alum Elizabeth “Libby” Castravet (née Potthast). He shared a video on his Instagram Stories of himself and Jenn enjoying drinks and posing together, as seen in a screen recording shared by the 90 Day Fiancé Update Instagram account on March 2, 2025.
“Josh Weinstein’s 90-Day Fiance mystery lady may have been revealed. Has he been hiding her for years?” the caption read. “This is Elizabeth Potthast‘s sister, Jenn, remember her? Josh actually knows their family since Elizabeth’s mom runs a casting agency. What do you all think? Does it look like a match made in heaven? P.S. He tagged Jenn on her IG.”
One day later, 90 Day Fiancé blogger Shabooty shared photos of Josh with a mystery blonde woman at the Las Vegas airport, boarding a flight to Phoenix. It’s unclear if the woman was Jenn.
Neither Josh nor Jenn has addressed the dating rumors. However, the two have been seen together in the past, including a February 2023 sighting while he was still involved with Natalie. At the time, Josh’s ex-wife, Candice Mishler, exclusively told In Touch that he and Jenn were “just friends.”
90 Day Fiancé’s Josh Weinstein and Natalie Mordovtseva Split on ‘The Last Resort’
Fans watched Josh and Natalie call it quits ahead of their recommitment ceremony during the March 17, 2025, episode of The Last Resort. In a final group therapy session, Josh told the Ukraine native that he didn’t want to “string her along anymore.”
“Natalie needs somebody 100 percent all the time and I’m scared to give that to her. I’m scared of commitment with her because I’m so unsure of what’s going to happen next,” he explained. “Maybe I’m the problem, maybe I’m showing too many breadcrumbs or stringing her along, or maybe she needs something more than I can give her and maybe that’s it.”
After they agreed to part ways immediately, Natalie told Josh, “Nothing matters unless you’re happy, and I honestly wish you happiness.”
Josh previously confirmed his split from Natalie in a February 2025 interview on “The Sarah Fraser Show” podcast.
“At the moment, I would say we are friends,” he said. “It’s definitely a lot to deal with but I guess we’ll see where it goes. I would say that it’s definitely been a wild ride with Natalie, and I care for Natalie a lot.”
Josh said he saw that Natalie was dependent on him and didn’t want to let her go out of fear that she wouldn’t have someone else to turn to.
“So, I always thought, if I wasn’t there to help, like, who’s going to be there for her?” he told host Sarah Fraser. “And so, that pulled on my heartstrings a lot and I think that kind of strung our relationship along a little bit, because I was holding on to like, well, I don’t know what’s going to happen to her, but I care for her.”
