Mike admitted he wasn’t in love with Natalie when he married her on the day her visa was about to expire. Natalie failed to get along with Mike’s mother and found an excuse to leave when she accused Trish Youngquist of calling her a “h**ker.” Natalie dreamed of a glamorous life which Sequim wasn’t going to give her. Natalie also gained weight and claimed Mike didn’t support her desire to be an actor. Eventually, Natalie walked out of the marriage and relocated to Florida. It was a move that would change Natalie’s life forever.

Natalie Has Been Married Thrice So Far

Natalie Had Two Ex-Husbands Before Mike

Natalie never mentioned Zenon on the show, but a major secret soon came to light. It was revealed that Natalie had been married to Zenon, much before her 90 Day Fiancé debut. Blogger 90daythemelanatedway posted pictures from Natalie’s wedding day. The couple was married for under two years, and Natalie was supposed to have stayed with Zenon in Cyprus during their marriage. However, she returned to Ukraine after Zenon allegedly filed for bankruptcy. It was there that she soon met her next husband, sparking further interest in her past and raising questions about her relationships.

Natalie Dated A Man Named Johnny Vance On The Single Life

Johnny Was An Aspiring Model Like Natalie

Natalie went to St. Petersburg in Florida when she left Sequim. She claimed the same reminded her of places back home. Natalie declared that she was still married but also didn’t want to be single for long. Natalie went on a blind date with a man named Johnny. Their first blind date was somewhat awkward, but Natalie agreed to go to a bar despite her dislike of alcohol. Nevertheless, aspiring model Johnny was eager to see her again and was hopeful for a second date. Natalie and Johnny’s second date was at a turtle sanctuary.

Johnny Helped Natalie Meet Josh

While in Florida, Natalie was trying to date and secure a modeling contract. It was Johnny who invited her to a modeling workshop. She felt insecure about her age being an obstacle in her career but tried to hide her concerns by saying, “I have a beautiful, perfect body. A beautiful face. I think I’m a goddess, honestly.” The workshop was hosted by Josh, who immediately told her, “Great job, see you in Hollywood,” which gave Natalie a burst of hope for her future. She was desperate to break into the modeling industry and build a career.

For their first date, Josh took Natalie to a golf course, where some light touching occurred, and this time, she didn’t mind it at all. “When he touches me, I feel comfortable and secure around him,” she admitted. Josh was confident that he’d get a kiss from Natalie by the end of the date. During their conversation, Natalie asked Josh if he was still married. He assured her he wasn’t, and when it was her turn to respond, she replied, “Too complicated”. However, by the end of the season, Natalie was ready to move to California for Josh.

Josh & Natalie Split On The Last Resort

Natalie Was Hurt By Josh’s Decision

“It kind of hurt my dignity a lot.”

However, Natalie vowed not to get involved in any “drama” or “scandal” after the breakup. She didn’t want to show the ugliness of their breakup to her co-stars because she felt she was better than that. The show’s therapists appreciated Josh and Natalie’s openness and vulnerability throughout their stay at the resort. They thought Josh and Natalie did a great job with their communication. Natalie’s friend Stacey Silva could see that Natalie still wanted more and deserved to be happy.

Who Is Natalie Dating A Year After Her Split With Josh?

Is Natalie Still Single?

90 Day: The Last Resort was filmed in March 2024. It has been a year since Josh and Natalie went their separate ways, and this time around, they didn’t get back together after the cameras stopped rolling. Stacey had observed how Natalie yearned for a healthy, loving, and committed relationship. She’d hoped that Natalie could find true love. This time around, Natalie seems to be taking things slow. In January 2025, Natalie hinted at the presence of a new man in her life. The man’s name starts with the letter “J,” just like Josh.